The Whos Down in Whoville have gone off the deep end

As if I could not be more disappointed lately, major shake ups are rumored at both Dr. Who and Torchwood according to SciFi Pulse. This is like cheap icing on a dry cake. The cake: the first episode of Dr. Who and Sarah Jane Chronicles that both contained questionable racial and body image narratives that with regards to the former, left me wondering if this would be the first season of Dr. Who I would not see all the way through (having seen the entire run of Dr. Who in my niñez). The second episode of the season, in Rome, is much more in keeping with what fans expect from the show: a bad CGI monster or two, Dr. Who saving the world while making quirky comments, and a few well placed comments/helpers from Tate and others. I wouldn’t say it was my favorite episode but it was good.

That being said here is the scoop:

  • Barrowman is rumored to be complaining there are too many episodes in a Torchwood season for him to do his other projects . . . so the rumor goes, he will be leaving next season early on and guesting once and a while

  • As I hinted at before, rumors have it that Freema will join the cast next season and she and Gwen will become the corner stones of the new “family friendly” version of Torchwood (bye Ianto)

  • Tennant will also be leaving the world of Who at season’s end being replaced by fellow Scott Robert Carlyle

Here’s the thing, Torchwood is built around Jack though it is an ensemble the folklore does not seem to stand up without either him or the Doctor present. It is also best when it is melancholy and dramatic, this is when the actors give their best performances, when the writers give us food for thought and snark to quote, and when the concept of the show itself shines as both implicated in the Dr. Who world but also a stand alone. A newer, tweenie, Torchwood where Gwen’s marital woes take center stage, Ianto puts the tea down and disappears without nary a snark nor a romp or turns into gun toting Ianto, and little kids suddenly live next door or worse are invisible sprites popping forth from the now evolved weevils sounds about as fun as as watching those insipid teletubbies. I love Freema, but I will not watch to see her and Gwen play tiddly winks for the tweens on Torchtubbies. What exactly is Marsters supposed to do in this world? Oh . . . steal Jack’s heart and take him away on wristband related adventures . . . I am suddenly getting worried by this rumor . . . worried.

I also happen to be a rather big fan of Robert Carlyle but as someone who has watched many an incarnation of the Doctor in my lifetime, and seen every episode of the entire show, much of it multiple times, all I can say is “I don’t think so.” I won’t watch. I won’t. It isn’t just that for me Tennant is like a mix of all of the best Doctor’s past, Carlyle just doesn’t fit the Converse.

I watch three shows for escapism: BSG (canceled & so far really bad this season), Dr. Who (soon to be canceled due to poor casting choices), and Torchwood (soon to be starring Tinky Winky cooing lovingly at Gwen) . . .

All I can say is: You are a mean one Mr. Grench! Bring the presents back to Whoville so we can all join hands and sing . . . or I may have to show you why you never ever piss off a celt. Let alone a feminist on the edge.


9 thoughts on “The Whos Down in Whoville have gone off the deep end

  1. Oh no! I didn’t know BSG was cancelled. I haven’t caught up yet because I haven’t seen Razor (was off on my honeymoon with no tv, much less cable, when it aired).And Tennant leaving? Say it ain’t so!Just out of curiosity, how do you feel about Heroes? It’s got it’s problems, especially on race, but it’s got enough cheesy sci-fi to meet my escapist tv needs.

  2. HM – no I don’t but Jenn at reappropriate has written on this show. (FYI – Razor’s major premise was anti-lesbian/homophobic, see gay prof’s piece on this.)

  3. Oh no, the new BSG season is really bad! I haven’t seen Razor but I got enough of the lesbophobic undercurrents in the Pegasus episodes. Not pretty.

  4. yep no one wants to see starbuck writhing on the floor; altho she’s gone again now so . . . Be warned, Razor was much much worse than Pegasus partially b/c of what you find out about why 6 was the ship’s sex/rape slave . . .

  5. Yuck. It sounds like I should just skip Razor entirely then. I could barely force myself to sit through the Pegasus eps. Does the new season make sense without seeing razor?

  6. deoridhe – one of the boys watches Bones, I think he has a crush on Angel. I watch something else at that time . . . don’t remember what.

  7. Smart boy; Angel is decidedly crush-able and he’s grown into a really good actor since the beginning of Buffy. They’re playing a lot with gender roles wrt the two main characters.If you go to the den of evil, the Fox website, they show some of the most recent episodes (full episodes). I don’t have a tv anymore, so that’s how I get my fix.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s