Libraries and Identities

So I’ve got to go in to campus this a.m. for a GLBT[QI] meeting, followed by an afternoon mediation between students. Long time readers know that Pov U is not a queer friendly campus and student meetings are largely done through secret/closed listservs and quickly circulated spots. Today’s meeting will be slightly more public than that b/c of a conflict seemingly between GLB students and a trans student. (I say seemingly b/c one of the issues at hand is whether there are trans students on both sides of the issue or not.) The public nature of the discussion makes it feel unsafe to many of the parties involved and it is likely that many of them will not show up. More importantly, it is likely that the bones of contention – who is trans and who gets to speak – will not be resolved as a result. Both I and a fellow faculty member have been asked to moderate by all sides as known members and allies that everyone involved respects. My fellow moderator has already sent me an email wishing he could get out of it b/c drama is likely. A similar online conflict that denigrates me without evidence could be my ticket out of it. Honestly we are both just really swamped untangling where the hurt happened, what the facts are, and how to work through the emotions and the identities that do not fit neatly into the alphabet, particularly those who do not feel they should have to identify, and then there are those who have identified but only under promise of anonymity which are now an important factor in the outcome of this conflict. Both of us however, will be there b/c we care about everyone involved, the sense of hurt and actual hurt, and the project at hand. g-d help us all.

I’m really stuck on how this all boils down to issues of trusting across difference, speaking from a place of care, and learning to navigate conflict in ways that recognize each others abilities, needs, and issues. It is not an easy task with the accusations are flying on all sides. It is harder when somethings are about what is known, what is made up to justify a position, and what is kept to oneself or in ones closet . . . This is probably the best time and the worst time for me to be doing this.

(I edited the rest of this post b/c some students involved are aware of the blog or matching the circumstances to our campus and its best we talk specifics on the listserv; but I didn’t want to delete any comments here either.)


6 thoughts on “Libraries and Identities

  1. Hey prof

    Thanks for telling me this was up. Many of us probably do need to weigh out what happened more but today’s meeting didn’t fix that.

    I wish you weren’t conferencing this week . . .

  2. umm, I think you are talking about our campus. & I’m one of those 3 trans students. I took a stand in the meeting today b/c the library thing wasn’t transphobic. but there were a lot of transphobic ppl in that room. thx for catchin’ that

  3. Welcome to the blog Luz, Chell, & Ryder. I don’t think it is ok to talk specifics of the meeting on a public blog, best to leave it to the campus listservs.

    thanks for stopping by and thanks for letting me know (some of you in person as well?) that you felt good about what we managed to accomplish today. More to do. But it looks like you all are committed to that.

  4. Hey! I watched that whole thing go down at the other blog + I got what u were trying to say. As a trans woman and transgender advocate, I just wanted to thank u for all u do. She’s already picked a fight w/2 new groups of people. Sometimes conflict is all we know. It takes a lot to unlearn.

    • welcome to the blog anon. When you work from a place of hurt and rejection it never leads anywhere good. If anything that is the lesson for everyone. (It was also the lesson at the library mediation. We are working actively on ways that marginalized communities can heal from their historic and present day hurts and speak across difference from a place that does not blame or shame but also embeds accountability for everyone. No one is accountable for the ways they are oppressed, but everyone is accountable for the ways they are oppressive. These moments help us, and me personally, sharpen those skills and recognize where they have become weak.)

      like I implied in the “keep talking post” best to close this thread and focus on the business of the work here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s